Why Didn’t a Rolling Stone Writer Talk to the Alleged Perpetrators of a Gang Rape?
Why didn’t a Rolling Stone writer talk to the alleged perpetrators of a gang rape at the University of Virginia?
By Allison Benedikt and Hanna Rosin
Photo by Todd Vance via Wikimedia Commons
The Rolling Stone piece “A Rape on Campus” is a huge story in all senses of the word. It is long and expansive, documenting a culture at the University of Virginia that seems to shrug off sexual assault. It has also helped kick off a broad national conversation about fraternity culture, rape on campus, and whether our colleges and universities are equipped to adjudicate alleged sex crimes. At its heart, though, Sabrina Rubin Erdely’s article is about a single event: an orchestrated gang rape of a woman named Jackie. In the course of 9, words, Erdely chronicles an administration’s tepid response to a terrible crime. But what the piece is missing is one small thing: that single, standard sentence explaining that the alleged perpetrators of the crime deny it, or don’t deny it, or even that they could not be reached for comment. It’s often a boring sentence, on
For anyone interested in a whole range of issues, from women&#;s rights to collegiate culture to the state of American journalism, the story at the heart of Calamity West&#;s Rolling was a big deal. The November 19, , issue of Rolling Stone magazine featured &#;A Rape on Campus,&#; Sabrina Rubin Erdely&#;s report on allegations made to her by a University of Virginia student called &#;Jackie,&#; who said she&#;d been lured into an upstairs room at the local Phi Kappa Psi fraternity house and gang-raped as part of an initiation rite. Erdely&#;s piece caused a furor, first, because of the misogynistic savagery of the crime—then, only days later, because it had become apparent that no crime had taken place. Turns out Jackie made the whole thing up. Rolling Stone repudiated &#;A Rape on Campus,&#; the Columbia School of Journalism issued a damning study of editorial lapses at the magazine, and various victims filed suit.
According to a program interview, West became fascinated by the tale. She found herself wondering about the disgraced Erdely, ultimately asking herself, &#;What would I do if I were her? Where would I go?&#; Her answer, she says, was, &#;I&#;d go home.&#; A
BY DEAN SEAL
Sabrina Rubin Erdely vehemently defended some of her reporting choices — and fell on her sword for others — in more than eight hours of testimony with an attorney for Nicole Eramo, the University of Virginia administrator suing Erdely and Rolling Stone magazine for $ million.
Among her most striking statements were her final words, in which she said unequivocally that Eramo was not damaged by her reporting in “A Rape on Campus” and that her portrayal was “fair and accurate” — as were many other aspects of the piece.
“I stand by everything I wrote … except for anything that came from Jackie,” Erdely said.
Erdely penned the infamous November article that focused on what she presented as a climate of sexual assault at UVa through the lens of several student survivors, including “Jackie,” a then-student who claimed she’d been gang raped at a fraternity house during her freshman year at UVa.
People are also reading…
At the time of the article’s publication, Eramo was the associate dean tasked with providing support for student survivors, mentoring Jackie and countless others. She now claims the article, retracted in April after a police invest
About: Sabrina Erdely
- Sabrina Rubin Erdely is an American former journalist and magazine reporter, who in authored an article in Rolling Stone describing the alleged rape of a University of Virginia student by several fraternity members. The story, titled "A Rape on Campus", was later discredited. The magazine retracted the article following a Columbia University School of Journalism review which concluded that Erdely and Rolling Stone failed to engage in "basic, even routine journalistic practice". As a result, Erdely was named in three lawsuits with demands of more than $32 million combined for damages resulting from the publication of the story. (en)
- Sabrina Rubin Erdely é repórter estadunidense de revista residente em Filadélfia, Pensilvânia, que se tornou conhecida em como autora de um artigo desacreditado publicado na Rolling Stone, descrevendo um estupro alegado por uma estudante da Universidade da Virgínia, por parte de vários membros de fraternidades. A história, intitulada "Um Estupro no Campus", foi depois averiguada, e constatou-se que não havia qualquer prova que lhe desse suporte. A revista retratou-se s
Biographies you may also like
Ewerdt hilgemann biography of rory gilmore To commemorate my finishing Gilmore Girls, I wanted to post her high school graduation speech which was delivered on the last episode of the third season. I think it is the Missing: ewerdt hilgemann.
Thunjathu ramanujan ezhuthachan biography definition Thunjathu Ramanujan Ezhuthachan (Malayalam: തുഞ്ചത്തു രാമാനുജന് എഴുത്തച്ഛന്, Tuñchattŭ Rāmānujan Eḻuttacchan; also known as: .
Kenny kunene and khanyi mbau imageshack Khanyisile Mbau is a South African actress, musician, television presenter and socialite. She received recognition as the second Doobsie on SABC 2's soap opera Muvhango (–); Missing: kenny kunene.
Daniel sluman biography Kaufen Sie "Absence Has a Weight of Its Own" von Daniel Sluman als eBook. Sofort-Download eBook verschenken. Der Artikel ist jetzt in Ihrem Warenkorb Popover schließen Der Artikel Missing: biography.
Criswell biography Speaker Bio: ato of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Ms. Criswell is the first woman confirmed to serve as the Administrator, where she leads the nation's effort in helping .
Edward weston photography photographer Edward Henry Weston (March 24, – January 1, ) was an American photographer. He has been called "one of the most innovative and influential American photographers" and "one .
Michel qissi tong po makeup -JCVD with the help of Stan Winston, the creator of the Predator design, made Michel Qissi look like Tong po. -Michel Qissi had to fly the entire way to Thailand in his Tong .
Beaumont newhall biography of william Known for his passion in photography and art history, Beaumont Newhall wrote five editions of The History of Photography, as well as working as a curator in museums, working as a college professor, and dedicating his life to improving the world of photography.